← All articles

A/B testing donation pages without manipulating your donors

Charities can and should test their donation journeys. How to do it in a way the Fundraising Regulator, your supporters and your trustees would all be comfortable with, and what to test first.

Jon Crowder7 minute read
A brown donkey braying on a grassy clifftop above the sea
Credit: Ansgar Scheffold (Unsplash)

When the new Code of Fundraising Practice came in on 1 November 2025, one of the changes that got noticed was about tips.

Online giving platforms that charge an optional fee, like JustGiving and GoFundMe, were told to give "equal prominence to options to pay no fee" and Civil Society reported that the regulator was in contact with platforms about the rule change.

Their example was JustGiving, which at the time added an automatic 17% tip that donors could lower or remove themselves. I actually remember using it multiple times when giving to various causes.

JustGiving's fees page called the tip voluntary and says that if you want to opt out you could choose "Enter custom amount" and enter 0. Equally, GoFundMe's pricing page says that donors can choose to tip but that it's never required.

Pre-set tips are a common default and defaults are just about the oldest trick in conversion optimisation. Most people will accept whatever's already selected and that is why they work, and also why a charity should think long and hard before using one.

A glass jar on a bar with a handwritten label reading Tip
Credit: Sam Dan Truong (Unsplash)

Charities should test

I think charities should run experiments on their donation journeys. Every pound lost to a confusing form or broken mobile page or uncompelling message is a pound that doesn't reach the cause and many of the charity sites I've seen have plenty of those.

One example. In my last agency job I worked with The Donkey Sanctuary, and they had a lot of people coming to the website to buy a gift. It was difficult to quantify exactly how many, but between their behaviour and what was coming out of the surveys we knew it was a sizeable chunk of the audience. They wanted a donation they could give as a sort of last-minute present for a friend or a family member.

A donkey seen from very close up, lips pulled back to show its teeth
Credit: Daniel Fazio (Unsplash)

That journey was almost completely unsupported by the site. You could do it, you could buy on someone else's behalf, but it was a toggle very, very late in the checkout. Up until that point almost every bit of messaging and every call to action was about you buying it for yourself. So anybody buying a gift had to sort of cosplay as somebody buying for themselves, right up to the checkout, where they'd finally find the toggle.

Most users obviously just don't make it that far. They go "oh, okay, this isn't going to be possible, they're going to send out a pack and it's not going to feel like a gift". What that person wants from the whole experience is to be reassured that when they give this as a gift it's going to feel like a thoughtful, well-thought-through idea, and there was nothing in the journey that would give you that signal at all.

Our suggestion was that they build a gifting journey, aimed at and structured around buying this for somebody else. It would cover what happens to the donkeys with the donation money, which was already a big part of the site, but also what the person receiving the gift will get and what they actually experience. It would let the charity offer upgrade options, sending out something from the gift shop along with the donation itself. It would take a lot of inspiration from services that are just gift buying, like Interflora when you buy flowers for somebody else. We thought we could get more money out of the transaction, and a better experience and a better product as well.

A hand holding out a bunch of flowers wrapped in printed brown paper
Credit: Ziyuang Wang (Unsplash)

We wanted to build that, test it really rigorously at every stage, and then get it out.

The rules you're already under

The Code of Fundraising Practice says fundraising must not put "undue pressure on a person to donate", must not use "unreasonably persistent approaches", and that charities must "take all reasonable steps to treat existing or potential donors fairly" so they can make an informed decision. There's also separate guidance on donors in vulnerable circumstances.

None of the Code explicitly mentions A/B testing. All of it applies to whatever goes live to real people, so a test that breaks the Code is as punishable as a 100% rolled out experience that breaks the code.

What's fair game

The thing that works really well is centring the donor in your overall experience and understanding what they want from it. With a charity, people are quite often doing this because they want to help. They want to do something about an issue that is dear to them, whether that's a social charity or an animal charity or any number of single-issue charities. They want to give some money and do some good and that is the thing their whole experience needs to be centred around.

So a charity can talk about:

  • The work, and how the money goes into it.
  • How much of the money gets there. One of the fears people have around charity is that of every £1 they donate, maybe only a fraction makes it to the person or the animal that needs it. You can communicate around that.
  • What donating is going to feel like. Somebody who becomes a regular donor might give £10 a month and you need to explain to that person what that's going to feel like, month after month. Are they going to get a newsletter that tells them what the money's been spent on? Some charities send letters from the people who are helped by the donation. You need to think about that whole experience and what it will be like, and then communicate it.
  • What it has been like for other people. Ideally you should commit to what happens next and if you cannot commit to future deliveries then explain what the experience has been like for people who have given in the past.
  • That a gift will be received well. As in the example above, if they're buying it as a gift you need to reassure them that the gift will be good and well received, that it will arrive on time, and that the individual parts of it will feel meaningful.

Somebody is buying something here. That the donation is good and the work it does is good and it does good in the world, but you've got to remember that the person giving this donation needs to be reassured, and it's actually kind of our job to make them feel really good about doing good.

I'm going to refrain from generalist advice about forms and website speed. I don't really think you should test speed at all. The fastest page you can have is always going to be the right thing to do. What you should test is the stuff that's contentious: how you communicate things, what people should get as part of it, what is particularly important and what is less important, what is expected and what is novel or interesting about the offering you have.

All of that stuff is really testable.

What to be careful with

These are the ones that can work in a test and yet still be the wrong thing to do both ethically and financially:

  • Pre-selected amounts. Suggested amounts might help people decide. Defaulting to intentionally higher ones or to monthly giving when someone came and gave lots of signals they intend to only give once, may look to a regulator a lot like the "tip" problem above.
  • Pre-ticked regular giving or extras. If someone has to notice and untick something to avoid paying more or giving away data then you'll struggle to prove it was given knowingly.
  • Guilt in decline options or choices. "No, I don't want to help more children" is confirmshaming but it's also, given the subject matter, incredibly manipulative and a brand reputation nightmare. Please do not do this or anything like it.
  • Fake urgency. Match-funding deadlines that are real are useful and good and positive. Fake ones aren't. Do not fake anything.
  • Exit pop-ups that plead. One polite reminder might be fine. A sequence of them may be considered "unreasonably persistent".

Measure more than the gift

A donation page that raises more today and loses more supporters next year categorically hasn't won. Attracting more regular givers who all immediately cancel because they feel misled is also not a winner.

When you test, I'd look at:

  • Donations per visitor, not just conversion rate, so a test can't win by attracting lots of smaller gifts.
  • Regular gift retention at three and six months for regular givers recruited by each variant. Are we keeping people by giving them what's expected and fair?
  • Complaints and refunds. If these go up, we've done something wrong.
  • Gift Aid take-up, because it's essentially extra money for the charity and a sign that people understood the form.

There's more on this in our piece on what charities can teach ecommerce about ethics, where we argue that ecommerce should look to charities and how they operate to understand what it means to treat your users well.

If you'd like help with your own donation journey, that's also something we do.

Jon Crowder runs Another Web Is Possible.

Sources

  1. Behaviour when fundraising, Fundraising Regulator, Code of Fundraising Practice, in effect from 1 November 2025
  2. Regulator in contact with fundraising platforms over zero tip rule change, Civil Society, 12 November 2025
  3. Our fees explained, JustGiving, read 19 November 2026
  4. Pricing, GoFundMe, read 19 November 2026

Ready to get started?

Book a Call